Karan Johar is facing criticism over a repeated question. His latest comparison of Ranbir Kapoor and Ranveer Singh on Koffee With Karan 9 has annoyed viewers, despite Varun Dhawan making his choice clear.

During the rapid-fire round, Karan asked Varun, “Ranveer Singh in Dhurandhar or Ranbir Kapoor in Animal, which one is a more impactful performance?” Varun replied, “I would definitely say Ranveer in Dhurandhar.” 

Why Are Netizens Annoyed With Karan Johar's Question?

Viewers are questioning why Karan keeps asking guests to compare the two performances. In the season's opening episode, he posed a similar question to Salman Khan, asking him to choose between Ranbir and Ranveer. Salman did not pick a winner but praised Ranveer's performance in Dhurandhar. The repeated comparison has now triggered fresh criticism on Reddit.

One user wrote, “Will he keep asking this to all the guests? Its like Deepika Alia thing he was doing in previous seasons. Trying to put Dhurandhar & Animal in same level.”

Another commented, “He's doing it again. The way he repeatedly asked Deepika or Alia until people believed they were at the same level. He's doing this to put Animal on the same level as Dhurandhar. Propaganda film or whatever, but story, acting performance, and box office-wise, Dhurandhar is way way ahead of Animal?”

A third user said, “This question is going to be the Alia Bhatt of the previous seasons.” Another asked, “What's this comparison lol? A deshbakht vs a Misogynist?” One more user wrote, “Kjo needs to stop comparing Dhurandhar with Animal. Poles apart, it’s an insult to Dhurandhar to be put in the same bracket as Vanga’s Animal.”

How Ranbir Kapoor and Ranveer Singh's Films Compare

Ranbir played Ranvijay Singh in Sandeep Reddy Vanga's Animal (2023), which follows a troubled father-son relationship and a path of violence and revenge. The film faced criticism for its portrayal of women but became a major commercial success, earning around ₹918 crore worldwide. Ranbir is next set to appear in Nitesh Tiwari's Ramayana, with the first part scheduled for November 5, 2026.

Ranveer played undercover agent Hamza Ali Mazari in Aditya Dhar's Dhurandhar. The film earned over ₹1,300 crore worldwide, while its sequel reportedly crossed ₹1,800 crore globally. The two films offer different roles and performances, but Karan's repeated comparison has become a separate talking point among viewers.